Same Name Episode Comparison

[Wazer]

Below is a list of episodes with the same or similar names within star trek and stargate

 

Which of these episodes do you prefer? Was the first one better or the second?

Which name was more appropriate?

 

For example

 

The TNG episode "The Emissary" was no where near as good as the later pilot episode for DS9 "Emissary" although it was useful in providing important background information on Worf.

I also feel the TNG episode could have used another name that was slightly more descriptive but Emissary as the title for the DS9 pilot was entirely appropriate.

 

Edit

Redemption Part 1+2 - TNG Season 4/5 - SG-1 Season 6 ( Courtesy TFMF )

[TFMF]

DS9 Emissary was much better and a great way to start the DS9 series

 

Who Mourns for Morn was a really funny ep and i enjoyed that very much

 

First Contact the Movie - i mean come on! - it wins hands down! :)

 

Nemesis - Movie!!!

 

Endgame - Voyager - i havn't actually seen the SG-1 version yet but it was still a good way to end Voyager...

 

Learning Curve - Voyager - great ep - CHEESE!!!

 

Message in a Bottle - Voyager - was a really funny episode - one of my favs i think

 

Family....i will go with TNG i think but it was a close one...

 

Rules of Engagement - DS9 - a great Trial for Worf...but again quite close...

 

Threshold - SG-1 - i didn't like the Voyager one really - i don't think anyone else did either...

 

Desperate Measures - DS9 - right in the heat of the Action at the end of DS9 builds the way to the best finale ever!

 

Meridian - SG-1 - this was a really sad ep in that Jackson died and i think it was much better compared to DS9 Meridian

 

Demon - Voyager - there were things i liked about the Ent one but i prefered this one...

[Arktis]

DS9 - 421 - The Muse & Voy - 622 - Muse